EXPOSED
The detection half of this job — spotting expired meters, reading plates, matching permits, printing and mailing citations — is already done better by license-plate-recognition cameras, in-ground sensors, and pay-by-app systems, and cities have been cutting routes accordingly. What survives is physical: walking a beat where cameras don't reach, booting and tagging vehicles for tow, clearing fire lanes and disabled spaces, handling the angry driver at the windshield, and testifying at adjudication hearings. This is a municipal job protected more by union contracts and city procurement inertia than by anything AI can't do.
Mixed — a routine tier and a judgment tier. At 8 the split is roughly even: meter checking, permit verification, and citation issuance are already replaced by LPR vans and app-based enforcement in most mid-size cities, but immobilizing with a boot, chalking tires on residential permit streets, coordinating tow trucks, and physically clearing a blocked hydrant still require someone on the curb — that's why it isn't a 4, and why it isn't 12.
Hands-on in uncontrolled environments. A 13 reflects eight-hour foot or scooter patrols in whatever weather the route delivers, kneeling in traffic to fit a wheel clamp, and standing between a tow hook and its owner — uncontrolled public street, but on a fixed and mapped beat rather than an unpredictable interior, which keeps it off the high end.
Certification preferred, not legally required. At 5 you may carry a municipal enforcement certification or state-mandated training, and your citation is a sworn document, but you hold no license that can be revoked and the city — not you — defends and voids the ticket when the adjudicator dismisses it.
Anonymous artifact production. A 4 is honest: the driver meets you once, at the windshield, already hostile, and the citation is legally identical whether you wrote it or a camera did — the only relational value is with the tow operators and business owners on your regular beat.
Executes defined procedures on defined inputs. At 5 nearly every call is spelled out — grace periods, curb-color codes, boot thresholds by number of unpaid tickets, ADA placard checks — with the real discretion limited to whether to void, whether to escalate to tow, and how you describe the violation when it reaches adjudication.
Has AI actually changed your work?