EXPOSED
The written half of this job — grant proposals, appeal letters, donor research briefs, LYBUNT segmentation, acknowledgment letters, impact reports — is exactly what current AI drafts at usable quality, and prospect-screening tools already rank wealth capacity better than a human scanning records. What survives is the part that requires a face across a table: cultivating a major donor over two years, judging when and how much to ask, and being the person a family trusts with a legacy gift. Modal worker here is a mid-level development officer whose week splits between screen work and donor meetings, so the job compresses toward relationship management rather than disappearing.
Mixed — a routine tier and a judgment tier. At 7 the balance tips just past the automatable line: the grant calendar, appeal copy, wealth-screening scores, moves-management data entry and gift acknowledgments are all machine-draftable, and what holds the number above 6 is the irreducible cultivation visit, the board-member-plus-prospect lunch, and the live ask where the number changes mid-conversation.
Some physical or field component. A 7 reflects that donor meetings, site tours, galas and regional travel put you off the desk several days a month, but the environments are boardrooms, homes and hotel ballrooms rather than anything uncontrolled — nobody's manual dexterity is load-bearing beyond a handshake and a check handoff.
No licence, no signature requirement. CFRE is voluntary and no state requires a licence to solicit — the charity itself files the state charitable-solicitation registration and the Form 990 Schedule G, and it is the CFO and board who sign, so a 2 rather than 0 only because paid-solicitor registration statutes in some states name individuals.
The human relationship is the product. 15 is right because a seven-figure bequest closes with the person the family has known for four years, not the institution: donors follow development officers to their next employer, and a transition mid-cultivation measurably delays or kills the gift.
Meaningful discretion. An 11 covers real discretion with a supervisor above it — you decide the ask amount, the timing after a spouse's death, whether to accept a restricted or non-cash gift, and when to walk away from a donor whose conditions compromise the mission — but gift-acceptance policies, the campaign plan and the ED's sign-off bound the largest calls.
Real Estate Sales Agents EXPOSED
Real Estate Brokers EXPOSED
Has AI actually changed your work?